Price Valuation - Large Collection/Lot

[sdpsc]

I was considering selling off a part of my collection, but wasn't sure what I might be able to get for it to know if it would be worth it to actually go through them.  But say, from sets 0-14, I have 1000 rares and foils or so to sell off, including mains and "good" cards.  Any guesses as to the value?

[Eukalyptus]

Depends mostly on the foils. Some R hold some value, but not that many, considering I can get staples like Cantea FTW in foil for about 1-2 bucks.

[sdpsc]

I believe this lot could have 594 foils, 238 of which are R, R+, P, RF, or O (3 Masterworks).  Does include foils from Reflections, Age's End, and the Wraith Collection.

Here's the list of those 238:

Faramir, Son of Denethor (P) [FOIL] [0P16]
Eowyn, Lady of Rohan (P) [FOIL] [0P17]
Smeagol, Old Noser (P) [FOIL] [0P18]
Fell Beast (P) [FOIL] [0P22]
Questions That Need Answering [FOIL] [1R81]
The Choice of Luthien [FOIL] [1R100]
The Misadventure of Mr. Underhill [FOIL] [1R129]
Uruk Guard [FOIL] [1R147]
Uruk Spy [FOIL] [1R155]
Cave Troll's Hammer [FOIL] [1R166]
Lost to the Goblins [FOIL] [1R189]
Frodo, Old Bilbo's Heir [FOIL] [1R289]
The Gaffer, Sam's Father [FOIL] [1R291]
Stone Trolls [FOIL] [1R314]
Gandalf, The Grey Wizard [FOIL] [1P364]
Aragorn, King in Exile [FOIL] [1P365]
Beneath the Mountains [FOIL] [2R1]
Gloin, Friend to Thorin [FOIL] [2R7]
Make Light of Burdens [FOIL] [2R11]
Realm of Dwarrowdelf [FOIL] [2R12]
What Are We Waiting For? [FOIL] [2R15]
Release the Angry Flood [FOIL] [2R19]
Jarnsmid, Merchant from Dale [FOIL] [2R25]
Staff Asunder [FOIL] [2R27]
Flaming Brand [FOIL] [2R32]
No Mere Ranger [FOIL] [2R36]
Shield of Boromir [FOIL] [2R38]
Beyond the Height of Men [FOIL] [2R39]
Lurtz's Sword [FOIL] [2R43]
Too Much Attention [FOIL] [2R45]
Uruk Captain [FOIL] [2R46]
Archer Commander [FOIL] [2R49]
The Balrog's Sword [FOIL] [2R50]
Cave Troll's Chain [FOIL] [2R53]
Final Cry [FOIL] [2R57]
Huge Tentacle [FOIL] [2R66]
Watcher in the Water, Keeper of Westgate [FOIL] [2R73]
Whip of Many Thongs [FOIL] [2R74]
Bill Ferny, Swarthy Sneering Fellow [FOIL] [2R75]
His Terrible Servants [FOIL] [2R77]
Stricken Dumb [FOIL] [2R80]
Ulaire Nelya, Ringwraith in Twilight [FOIL] [2R84]
The Witch-king, Lord of the Nazgul [FOIL] [2R85]
Wraith-world [FOIL] [2R86]
Verily I Come [FOIL] [2R94]
Consorting With Wizards [FOIL] [2R97]
Fearing the Worst [FOIL] [2R100]
Mithril-coat [FOIL] [2R105]
O Elbereth! Gilthoniel! [FOIL] [2R108]
Orc-bane [FOIL] [2R109]
A Promise [FOIL] [2R112]
Red Book of Westmarch [FOIL] [2R113]
Gimli, Dwarf of the Mountain-race [FOIL] [2P121]
Mines of Khazad-Dum [FOIL] [3R3]
Nenya [FOIL] [3R23]
Citadel of Minas Tirith [FOIL] [3R40]
Morgul Slayer [FOIL] [3R93]
The Shire Countryside [FOIL] [3R113]
Legolas, Son of Thranduil [FOIL] [3P121]
Hill Chief [FOIL] [4R20]
Hillman Mob [FOIL] [4R23]
No Refuge [FOIL] [4R29]
Wild Man Raid [FOIL] [4R39]
Dwarven Foresight [FOIL] [4R45]
Gimli, Lockbearer [FOIL] [4R48]
Rest by Blind Night [FOIL] [4R54]
Treebeard, Earthborn [FOIL] [4R103]
Boromir, My Brother [FOIL] [4R111]
Driven Back [FOIL] [4R149]
Elite Crossbowmen [FOIL] [4R150]
Grima, Wormtongue [FOIL] [4R154]
Lieutenant of Orthanc [FOIL] [4R158]
No Dawn for Men [FOIL] [4R163]
Orthanc Champion [FOIL] [4R164]
Saruman, Black Traitor [FOIL] [4R173]
Uruk Follower [FOIL] [4R186]
Wounded [FOIL] [4R215]
Rapid Fire [FOIL] [4R243]
Southron Assassin [FOIL] [4R246]
Southron Troop [FOIL] [4R256]
Aldor, Soldier of Edoras [FOIL] [4R262]
Eowyn's Sword [FOIL] [4R272]
Firefoot [FOIL] [4R274]
Helm! Helm! [FOIL] [4R279]
Weapon Store [FOIL] [4R294]
Frodo's Cloak [FOIL] [4R303]
Pippin, Just a Nuisance [FOIL] [4R313]
Sam's Pack [FOIL] [4R317]
Theoden, Lord of the Mark [FOIL] [4P365]
Be Back Soon [FOIL] [5R21]
These Are My People [FOIL] [5R41]
Grima, Chief Counselor [FOIL] [5R51]
Galadriel, Keeper of Nenya [FOIL] [6R18]
Naith Warband [FOIL] [6R23]
News From the Mark [FOIL] [6R96]
Gate Picket [FOIL] [6R101]
Preparations [FOIL] [7R12]
Bow of the Galadhrim, Gift of Galadriel [FOIL] [7R18]
Citadel to Gate [FOIL] [7R33]
Moment of Respite [FOIL] [7R44]
The Dead City [FOIL] [7R56]
Sneaking! [FOIL] [7R73]
Southron Marksmen [FOIL] [7R167]
Morgul Detachment [FOIL] [7R191]
Grimbold, Marshal of Rohan [FOIL] [7R233]
Legions of Morgul [FOIL] [7R283]
Stronghold of Cirith Ungol [FOIL] [7R314]
Reckless We Rode [FOIL] [8R12]
Morgul Squealer [FOIL] [8R77]
Merry, Noble Warrior [FOIL] [8P121]
The One Ring, The Binding Ring [9R+1]
Durin III, Dwarven Lord [9R+3]
Gimli, Bearer of Grudges [9R+4]
Linnar, Dwarven Lord [9R5]
Ring of Accretion [9R6]
Ring of Fury [9R+7]
Ring of Guile [9R8]
Ring of Retribution [9R9]
Sindri, Dwarven Lord [9R10]
Uri, Dwarven Lord [9R11]
Aiglos [9R+12]
Elven Rope [9R13]
Galadriel, Bearer of Wisdom [9R+14]
Gil-galad, Elven High King [9R+15]
Glorfindel, Revealed in Wrath [9R+16]
Knife of the Galadhrim [9R+17]
Merry's Dagger [9R18]
Narya, Ring of Fire [9R19]
Nenya, Ring of Adamant [9R20]
Pippin's Dagger [9R21]
Strands of Elven Hair [9R22]
Vilya, Ring of Air [9R23]
Ent Draught [9R24]
Huorn [9R25]
Sent Back [9R27]
Gollum, Dark as Darkness [9R+28]
Slippery as Fishes [9R+29]
Smeagol, Bearer of Great Secrets [9R+30]
Boromir, Bearer of Council [9R+31]
Elendil, The Tall [9R+32]
Isildur, Bearer of Heirlooms [9R+33]
Narsil, Blade of the Faithful [9R+34]
Sapling of the White Tree [9R35]
Scroll of Isildur [9R36]
Seeing Stone of Minas Anor [9R37]
Seeing Stone of Orthanc [9R38]
Library of Orthanc [9R+39]
Sack of the Shire [9R40]
Host of Moria, Legion of the Underdeeps [9R+41]
Ring of Asperity [9R42]
Ring of Rancor [9R44]
Horn of the Mark [9R45]
The Red Arrow [9R46]
Sauron, The Lord of the Rings [9R+48]
Bilbo, Bearer of Things Burgled [9R+49]
Everyone Knows [9R50]
Goldberry, River-daughter [9R+51]
Tom Bombadil, The Master [9R+52]
Great Day, Great Hour [FOIL] [10R1]
Drawing His Eye [FOIL] [10R29]
Ulaire Toldea, Thrall of the One [FOIL] [10R71]
Speak No More to Me [FOIL] [10R100]
Elven Marksmanship (F) [11RF2]
Gollum, Skulker (F) [11RF5]
Smeagol, Scout and Guide (F) [11RF6]
Aragorn, Strider (F) [11RF7]
Bloodthirsty (F) [11RF8]
Fletcher of Harad (F) [11RF9]
Undisciplined (F) [11RF11]
Gamling, Defender of the Hornburg (F) [11RF12]
Sword Rack (F) [11RF13]
Salt from the Shire (F) [11RF14]
Brawling Uruk (F) [11RF15]
Lurtz, Minion of the White Wizard (F) [11RF16]
The Pale Blade, Sword of Flame (F) [11RF17]
Faramir, Dunadan of Gondor (O) [12O2]
Ulaire Enquea, Black Threat (O) [12O8]
Elrond, Witness to History (F) [12RF1]
Hadafang (F) [12RF2]
Gandalf, The White Rider (F) [12RF3]
Faramir, Dunadan of Gondor (F) [12RF4]
Faramir's Sword (F) [12RF5]
Castamir of Umbar, Corsair Vandal (F) [12RF6]
Grima, Betrayer of Rohan (F) [12RF7]
The Mouth of Sauron, Lieutenant of Barad-dur (F) [12RF11]
Bilbo, Melancholy Hobbit (F) [12RF12]
Uruk Zealot (F) [12RF13]
Ulaire Attea, Black Predator (F) [12RF15]
The Witch-king, Black Lord (F) [12RF18]
Gandalf, Bearer of Obligation (O) [13O4]
Frodo, Frenzied Fighter (F) [13RF15]
Sentry Uruk (F) [15RF14]
Barrow-wight Stalker [16R1]
Candle Corpses [16R2]
Covetous Wisp [16R3]
Dead Faces [16R4]
Spirit of Dread [16R5]
Undead of Angmar [16R6]
The One Ring, The Great Ring [19P1]
Gimli, Opinionated Guide [19P2]
Still Twitching [19P3]
That's Two! [19P4]
Army Long Trained [19P5]
Arwen, Royal Maiden [19P6]
Legolas, Skeptical Guide [19P7]
Gandalf, Wise Guide [19P8]
Stern Words [19P9]
Gollum, Threatening Guide [19P10]
Smeagol, Pitiable Guide [19P11]
Aragorn, Well-traveled Guide [19P12]
Boromir, Destined Guide [19P13]
Not Bound To His Fate [19P14]
Strength In My Blood [19P15]
Grima, Servant of Another Master [19P16]
Urgency [19P17]
The Balrog, Demon of Might [19P18]
Reaching Tentacle [19P19]
Strong Tentacle [19P20]
Watcher in the Water, Many-Tentacled Creature [19P21]
Pit Troll [19P22]
Troll of the Deep, Cave Troll [19P23]
Brought Down From Inside [19P24]
Eomer, Eored Captain [19P25]
Eowyn, Lady of the Mark [19P26]
Sauron's Might [19P27]
Frodo, Little Master [19P28]
Merry, Resolute Friend [19P29]
Pippin, Steadfast Friend [19P30]
Rabbit Stew [19P31]
Sam, Loyal Friend [19P32]
Lurtz, Resilient Captain [19P33]
In Twilight [19P34]
Ulaire Attea, Dark Predator [19P35]
Ulaire Enquea, Dark Threat [19P36]
Ulaire Lemenya, Dark Enemy [19P37]
Ulaire Nertea, Dark Horseman [19P38]
Ulaire Toldea, Dark Shadow [19P39]
The Witch-king, Dark Lord [19P40]

[Eukalyptus]

Most of those don‘t break the 1$ barrier imho, I‘d value the big chunk below that actually. What could bring 3-5 or so bucks would be the R+ from Reflections, but not all of them. Gil-galad, Aiglos and Ring of Fury mostly. But past that I don‘t see value

Otherwise somewhat interesting foils I can see in your list are Grima WT and CC, Morgul Squealer, The Balrog DoM, Ulaire Nertea DH and the Wraith Collection.

What did you have in mind for the lot?

[sdpsc]

I wasn't really sure what the lot would be worth, to set any sort of price for.  So I'm open to suggestions there.

Would the 1000+ non-rare foils and non-foil rares I have (not listed) from sets 0-14 have any value?