@Dmessy: Cool article. I see very little that
might be added. In Movie block, you lose access to
Saruman KoI's protection, but you get access to Gollum (high vitality) and 2 of his tricks:
Sweeter Meats and
Final Strike. Perhaps that's worth mentioning, or perhaps not.
Final Strike helps to prevent directed arrows, but will also shield you against
Vilya.
@Dictionary: Yes, there are very little cards that refer to "ranged weapons" specifically. But those that refer to any "weapon" and can interact with "ranged weapons" that suit their specifications, those cards must be included.
Cantea, LoDG and
Stricken Dumb are examples, and are present both the Hand weapon and the Ranged weapon articles.
The Hand weapon article mentions only cards that refer to "weapons" or "hand weapons", but should list
Grond HotU too as it counters any non-companion FP card. The Wiki is meant to help beginners and those with less knowlegde, to them that info will be very valuable.
That article has many errors and unnecessary info. I don't take it as an ideal reference, just as a template of what has been done before (apparently was made by a machine mostly). For instance
Hand Axe,
Flaming Brand and
The Balrog's Sword are listed as "Cards that support Hand Weapons" only because can be borne with another hand weapon
. I'll list them as a separate category: "Hand Weapons that can be borne with another Hand Weapon", or something similar. Another error:
Isengard Axe says "when you play this weapon, add
![[1]](https://lotrtcgdb.com/forums/Smileys/classic/1.png "1")
" and for that superficial wording was included as a "card that supports hand weapons"
.
Anduril FotW is meantioned as a card that supports hand weapons, but counters yours in fact...
The article lists 1st the "support cards", 2nd the "counter cards", and 3rd the real "hand weapon possession / artifacts" appear. That's another mistake, which makes it much harder to read.
Some "Cards that support
possession weapons" can be listed too, in a separate list. That includes
Armory and
Ecglaf, or
Gamling Warrior of Rohan and
Rohirrim Scout. Or
Sword Rack,
Simbelmyne, even
These Are My People... Those form very devastating engines to work with weapons (but the only sin they commit is to mention "possessions" instead of "weapons"). Those should be mentioned for the sake of beginners and curious deckbuilders. Which is the goal of the Wiki, I think.
Copy-pasters have the posts on "Lothlórien" to read, that's more than enough for them.
All in all, we must reform those articles. I'll try to work on those points mentioned. And thanks for the feedback!!
EDIT: Worked all points mentioned on Hand Weapons, except creating the new lists of "Cards that support Possession Hand Weapons" and "Cards that counter Possession Hand Weapons".
-
Elven Bow I think the same. The FOTR
Elven Bow** should be the only with a narration and Strong/Weak vs lists. If we split it into each format's reprint, readers may not get important information they are searching for, if they click on the link of a version of another format. Besides, it's much simpler.
Yes,
Gimli Son of Gloin (P is a good example!
Topic: Article Feedback (Read 29066 times)
