My first rare from a booster was Savagery to Match Their Numbers. My brother bought his first packs at the same time, and he got Lurtz, Servant of Isengard and Ulaire Attea, Keeper of Dol Guldur... ...
To make room for extra conditions, I’d say take out So Polite and Shelob, Eater of Light. Captured by the Ring is sufficient to resurrect Gollum, so you don’t need Web out right away (plus Shelob...
IMO, put a few more copies of your Gollum conditions (Incited, Promise Keeping, They Stole It, Fat One Wants It, Hidden Even From Her) to make sure you get them out sooner.
If you’re worried about being corrupted, try a few copies of Not Listening, No Help for It, Salt from the Shire, or Impatient and Angry. There’s a lot of burden removal cards in the Shire culture...
After being disappointed by several other retailers, I finally found one that exceeds my expectations. Cobra Cards has great prices, great selection, awesome service, a convenient site layout, and fa...