sounds complicated since having Tuilin dies creates a time quandary I would create another character most likely a knight of dol amroth. you would be in charge of this right?

You start with a character (if people want to do DCs, I’d be fine with that - although you’ll need to be able to be in a starting fellowship regardless of other companions). If we get a larger number of people, we can have the Fellowship be played, ideally by one person (reasoning soon) with the goal of getting the One Ring from Rivendell to Mount Doom (but doesn’t have to).

I would say this is out. It was tried, and became very boring. (too read at least, no offence.)

I love the idea of having groups that travel and it takes them longer time to get some where, based on how they are clad, and what class they are in. What you could do is break the RPG’s into parts, and have one section one time, and another section another time. It would then fit under one topic, but you could have them at seperate times, which would be good for people who don’t always have time to post.

I don’t think we should as an RPG go and change a main a character (like ARagorn’s) life to dramatically, which would differ Tolkein’s way of which he wrote it.

Hopefully there won’t be to much DC-ing. FF ROCKS!