So...what's my card worth?

[MR. Lurtzy]

@ Lumpkin... Those would probably each go for at least $20-$25.

@Shilling... I'd be willing to pay for some of those sets as SOOK listed them.

[Mythdracon]

I already asked this, but I'd like to see some other opinions on this, since the Jord was the only one who responded prior:
-----------------------------

Is this fair?

Frenzy of Arrows x3
Black Land Overlord x3
Black Land Chieftain x2
Black Land Shrieker x2
Elendil's Army
Gollum, Threatening Guide x2
Shelob, Menace
Shelob, Her Ladyship x2
Scouring of the Shire
Morgul Gates
Not This Time!
Coordinated Effort
Gothmog, Morgul Leader

in trade for:

Bill Ferny, AoS
Well-crafted Armor
Beorning Axe
Arwen's Bow foil
Blood Runs Chill x2
Seasoned Leader x2
Treachery
Desert Lord
Back to the Light
Dinendal, Mirkwood Archer
Guidance of the Istari x2

I don't think it is, but what do you guys think?

[MR. Lurtzy]

My opinion is that the second group does not have enough cards on it for it to be fair.

[FingolfinFinwe]

Hm yeah its tough to compare visually because of the five rares that are x2.  I agree with Lurtzy and think that though Ferny is the prize card in the lot, the first group still has more value overall.

[Elessar's Socks]

Would anyone be willing to give a price breakdown for the rares in Mythdracon's list? Just trying to figure out why the trade is so unbalanced.

Group 1:
12 rares (5 Hunters, 4 TD), 2 Age's End, 7 uncommons
High-end: Scouring of the Shire

Group 2:
1 TD RF, 11 rares (3 Hunters, 3 TD), 2 uncommons
High-end: Bill Ferny, AoS; Beorning Axe; Arwen's Bow (foil)

[Vroengard]

I do not understand, too mate

Prices from ccg obsession:

Mine: 78,00 (rounded)

Mythdracon: 68,00 ---70,00 (rounded)

You can see, that it is me, whom he is trading with

[King89]

I do not understand, too mate

Prices from ccg obsession:

Mine: 78,00 (rounded)

Mythdracon: 68,00 ---70,00 (rounded)

You can see, that it is me, whom he is trading with

my dear friend... how often should i repeat myself: do not always trust in ccg obsession!

[Vroengard]

Have I done, I do not think so?? It is a reference...and even without, there is no reason to complain

[Elessar's Socks]

Well, I'll take a shot at this. Think of it as a question, more than a statement--what prices should be increased/decreased? Just so both sides are on the same page.

Frenzy of Arrows x3
Black Land Overlord x3
Black Land Chieftain x2 - $3 each
Black Land Shrieker x2 - $3 each
Elendil's Army - $3
Gollum, Threatening Guide x2 - $2 each
Shelob, Menace - $4
Shelob, Her Ladyship x2 - $3 each
Scouring of the Shire
Morgul Gates - $3
Not This Time! - $4
Coordinated Effort
Gothmog, Morgul Leader - $4

$40 + Scouring of the Shire + 7 uncommons

Bill Ferny, AoS
Well-crafted Armor - $4
Beorning Axe
Arwen's Bow foil
Blood Runs Chill x2 - $4 each
Seasoned Leader x2 - $3 each*
Treachery - $3
Desert Lord - $2
Back to the Light - $3
Dinendal, Mirkwood Archer - $4
Guidance of the Istari x2

$30 + Bill Ferny, AoS + Beorning Axe + Arwen's Bow (foil) + 2 uncommons

(Seasoned Leader is worth a lot to some people, but The Rendezvous Point still sells them for $1.50 each.)

[FingolfinFinwe]

Well Black Land Chieftain and Not This Time are more like $5.00 IMO, but your point is made.  It's not really that uneven.

[Elessar's Socks]

Yeah... Hunters and TD prices are tricky. I would say the Black Land guys are the cheaper ones and a piece of cake to find, but question is if I underestimated one side much more than the other. My feeling is that several of the prices listed so far in the first group have the potential to be higher... but then the biggies in the second group might make up the difference. Anyone have estimates for Scouring of the Shire; Bill Ferny, AoS; Beorning Axe; and Arwen's Bow (foil)?

[sickofpalantirs]

Aragorn, Heir to the Throne of Gondor
Faramir, Captain of Ithilien

I have a friend who has both of these...just wondering.

[Fatty_Lumpkin]

How does this look? someone offered it to me earlier today:

His:
Dwarven Foresight (foil)
Men of Harad (foil)
Volley Fire (foil)
Held Ground (foil)

My:
Horn of Boromir (foil)
Aragorn, Defender of Free Peoples (foil)
A Royal Welcome (foil) UC
Friends of Old (foil) C

[Vroengard]

Would that be fair:

Ugluk, ugly fellow

for

Gandalf, returned

??

[FingolfinFinwe]

SoP: $6-8 each maybe?

Fatty: Seems fair to me, you're getting 4 rares foils and giving two good rares foils and two uncommon foils.

Vroengard: Both are power cards so I'd say its even, though Gandalf, Returned might be a little more value seeing as its RoS.