So...what's my card worth?

[sickofpalantirs]

how much is faramirs sword O-foil worth
12RF14   Dark Approach (F)
12RF16   •Ulaire Cantea, Black Assassin (F)

[Olorin]

each about 4 $ perhaps...

[MR. Lurtzy]

And $8 for Faramir.

[sickofpalantirs]

thanks!
also just pulled Elrond witness to history FOIL, whats he worth?

[Olorin]

Hi there,

would that trade be fair?

Trade 1:

The One Ring, The Ring of Doom, 15R FOIL
Mount Doom, 15R FOIL
Last Gasp, 15R
The Witchking, Black Lord (O) 12O
Ulaire Cantea, Faster than winds, 7R
Blood runs chill, 8R

for

Throne of Minas Tirith (O) 17O Masterwork FOIL


Trade 2:

1x Gothmog Morgl Leader
1x Gothmog Morgul Leader FOIL
2x Scouring of the Shire
2x Gil-Galad High-king of the Noldor
1x Shelob Menace FOIL
1x Shelob Menace
+ a Rise of Saruman rare

for

2x Ulaire Otsea, Duplicitous Specter (O) 17O

[Olorin]

What would be the value of

Aragorn Defender of Rohan (O) 17O Masterwork FOIL?

[FingolfinFinwe]

SoP - prob $4

Olorin - Trade 1: person trading One Ring F is is trading alot.
Trade 2: Close to even

Always tough to tell when dealing with these level of cards though.

Never seen a regular Aragorn DoR MW sell, so I don't know.  Prob $70 US like the rest of the RoS MW

[MR. Lurtzy]

Olorin

Trade 1-fair

Trade 2- Second guy is getting ripped off.

[sickofpalantirs]

I disagree on the second one, its roughly equal, leaning towards second guy cheating the first.

first trade, ring of doom F seems highly sought after, possibly tad unfair for person 1.

[MR. Lurtzy]

In the second trade, second guy is trading away TWO RoS masterworks foils. Those  go for $60-70 on ebay all the time.  There is no way that

1x Gothmog Morgl Leader
1x Gothmog Morgul Leader FOIL
2x Scouring of the Shire
2x Gil-Galad High-king of the Noldor
1x Shelob Menace FOIL
1x Shelob Menace
+ a Rise of Saruman rare

is worth $140.

[MuadDib85]

What are these are worth?:

Watcher At Sarn Ford Masterworks
Radagast's Herb Bag Masterworks
Theoden Northman King Of Rohan RF

[MuadDib85]

Is this a fair trade??


White Hand Warrior x2 
pavise
heavy axe x3 
quickbeam, hoae
no pauses, no spills
dwarven bracers x2
Chamber Of Records
The Fortunes Of Balin's Folk
G for Grand x3
Riddermark Soldier
Our Foes Are Weak x2
Namarie 
Spied from Afar
Primitive Savage
Unseen Foe
Quickbeam HOAE RF 

for

17O7 •Ulaire Otsea, Duplicitous Specter (O) 

[King89]

What are these are worth?:

Watcher At Sarn Ford Masterworks ~ $12
Radagast's Herb Bag Masterworks ~ $15
Theoden Northman King Of Rohan RF ~ $15

that's what i would suggest.

[King89]

In the second trade, second guy is trading away TWO RoS masterworks foils. Those  go for $60-70 on ebay all the time.  There is no way that

1x Gothmog Morgl Leader
1x Gothmog Morgul Leader FOIL
2x Scouring of the Shire
2x Gil-Galad High-king of the Noldor
1x Shelob Menace FOIL
1x Shelob Menace
+ a Rise of Saruman rare

is worth $140.

i agree with you: if you add the single worth of each card max. $ 100 for all of them together.

[King89]

Is this a fair trade??


White Hand Warrior x2 
pavise
heavy axe x3 
quickbeam, hoae
no pauses, no spills
dwarven bracers x2
Chamber Of Records
The Fortunes Of Balin's Folk
G for Grand x3
Riddermark Soldier
Our Foes Are Weak x2
Namarie 
Spied from Afar
Primitive Savage
Unseen Foe
Quickbeam HOAE RF 

for

17O7 •Ulaire Otsea, Duplicitous Specter (O) 

i counted 1x 15RF, 4x "normal 15R" (means they aren't high-end), 1x 12R and some C/UC stuff. that's not enough for a MW from RoS now a days.