Just seeing if there's any interest in this. My idea is that each person creates a fictional character to RP, then we throw them all together into Troy and the aftermath(S). ie, The Iliad, Troilus and Cresyde, Odyssey, Aeneid, and Ynglingsaga, plus anything else we happen to create. Not technically LotR, but it's got some related elements....
And we can (to some degree) ignore realism as far as geography goes. For example, I have no problem with incidents in an Odyssey storyline influencing incidents in an Ynglingsaga storyline.
(Ynglingsaga, BTW, talks about how a bunch of Trojans escaped Troy besides just Aeneas, and traveled North. their names were Thor, Votan, etc.)