Hey all, glad to see this messageboard here as I thought LOTR TCG all but dead!
I've sold a bunch of LOTR promos over the past year on eBay. Here's some of the prices I got for stuff for reference -- dunno if they would still be selling for that amount or not.
Watcher at Sarn Ford 0P129 $36 May 26, $78 Feb 17
Primitive Brand 0P128 $30 May 26, $78 Feb 17
Lurtz, Now Perfected 0P126 $30 May 26, $90 Feb 17
Aragorn, Swift Hunter 0P122 $30 May 26, $78 Feb 17
Legolas, Fleet-footed Hunter 0P124 $14 May 25, $17 May 21, $17 Feb 15
Keening Wail 0P96 $3 May 24, $2 May 22
Gimli, Eager Hunter 0P123 $13 Feb 15
Also, I remember during Gen Con 2005, picking up a
Faramir, Prince of Ithilien 0P117 from Bojo at Decipher's booth (the last year they had one; it was tiny) and selling it on eBay that day for $70.

Paid for my registration...