Lady of Ithilien Clarification

[uncle_elrond]

Her text says that the opponent must wound a minion for each wound on a minion that she is skirmishing.  In this game I was playing, she was fight an exhausted Cave Troll.  I use her text to make the opponent assign 3 wounds.  He gives one to a Goblin Runner and it dies.  Then he says that he assigned all three wounds to it so he doesn't have to give out any more.  I tried to explain that after the first the Runner was dead so it couldn't be assigned any more wounds so the other 2 still had to be given to his other minions, but he said that they can all go to the same minion and any extra are discarded.  I said that would be true if that was the only minion on table.  After the Runner, there were still 3 minions left that could take the wounds.  He said they didn't have to take them, but I said he still did.  I think I am right, but I wanted this clarified in case I run into this problem again. 

[Tbiesty]

You are right.

With his argument your opponent could give you 10 archery and you could say back to him "I'll assign all the wounds to Goblin Runner".

[uncle_elrond]

Thanks guys.

[Elessar's Socks]

Could he have misinterpreted the "for each" rule? Otherwise, that is serious mistreatment of the Runner.

[uncle_elrond]

The only thing I can see is if he assumed that "wound a minion" meant assigning the wounds to only one minion.  I probably should have compared it to say Might of Numenor for another example.  I think the heal a companion part could be comparable to maybe make it clearer.

[Doom]

Thats the most brokennest runner ever o.o