Post your Gemp-LotR bugs here

[daisukeman]

From "the hobbit: the short rest" set..

Wicked spider minion does not pump by discarding an orc; not sure if it is happening always or only when spotting 6 companions.

replay link:
http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=daisukeman$s5e7yk0gpbu5z5kq
(possibly around site 7)

[daisukeman]

A few other bugs in that same format (the hobbit):

1. Bombur does not give damage +1
2. Gloin exerts and boosts himself +2 strength (instead of +3)
3. Dawn will take you all: seems bugged when trying to wound at least
4. Gandalf Leader of Dwarves: costs 4 albeit showing cost 2 (so no other starting companion is possible).
5. And... the best bug ever so far!... :
Revenhill (site 9) lets you discard a minion at maneuver but that minion's possesions (or at least the goblin scimitar) ends up floating about "somewhere"--visually- though hidden behind somehow the replacing minion.


I had seen some of these before on my own, though most of the above were pointed out by my opponent, so my replay link only shows it from this side:
http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=daisukeman$6pkwfstr779tmc09

Br,

[Phallen Cassidy]

Wicked Spider, Gloin, and Gandalf will be fixed once I push the latest errata for The Hobbit to the server. Still working on Bombur and Dawn Take You All (same issue that Deathless Lord used to have, if a minion cannot be wounded twice the Free Peoples player is forced to try to discard a Troll). I think I might have to wait for MarcinS to fix Ravenhill.

[daisukeman]

Thanks!
Ravenhill's bug is the least affecting one. May not have a consequence other than visually unless you may want to play that scimitar again and you can't.. but then again can't think if this is possible or not during maneuvers.

A couple of more bugs:
1. Beorn = Isn't discarded if not attached.
2. Bert = His respose is triggered by dawn take you all (when discarding a troll instead of a condition).
3. Bolg = Isn't damage+1 as stated on his text (at least the version which can bear a mount ..that one which is not sauron culture)

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=daisukeman$f3ynjt84hfw2u6b6

[Phallen Cassidy]

Beorn, Bert, Bolg, and Bombur will be in the next batch. Still working my way down to the Ds for Dawn Take You All

[daisukeman]

Great, thanks!
While we are at this, jot down that Gollum assignment hability is not working as well, because now it doesn't say he needs to be underground but not roaming.

As a separate discussion, any chance making an errata for Gandalf "the Grey"?
He is by far the best version and too OP to just wound any minion.
A suggestion could be to exert instead; or another one could be "wound any minion not assigned to skirmish"; or a minion with certain X cost --or below; or rather make the shadow player wound a minion; or yet another one could be leaving it as it is but put a limit (e.g. 1 per site).

[Phallen Cassidy]

Gandalf, the Grey has an upcoming errata, but it only makes it so he cannot wound Smaug with his text. Other than that, you'll need to take it up with Enola in one of his Hobbit threads, or start a new one.

You'll have to post a replay for Gollum, need more detail to figure out what part of the effect is causing it to fail.

[zaksirak]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=zaksirak$wqiz92nz31dufpzu
Bolg didn't give damage bonus on site 2 and Narzog bugget game completely on site 4. Narzog did this to me twice today when I played on my iPhone. First time I was by PC, so i logged in and I could continue. On iPhone I just couldn't click anywere on the screen.

[Valtor]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Valtor$tbfdsut1opclcvxg

At site 3, Battle of Azanulbizar did not work for Valtor against a single orc with one vitality. Surely it should have been able to wound the orc, even though it could not apply the second wound?

At site 5, Gollum Small Slimy Creature did not work for Valtor, his Assignment ability was not active.

At Site 6, Valtor's Narzug Orkish Assassin seemed to be available to wound an ally twice and then to do it again (couldn't because no target, but the action was active twice, see replay).

At site 6, after carnifex's  reconcile, Laketown "required triggered effect is used" was activated, even though it did nothing.

At site 7, carnifex was not able to discard 2 cards from his 5 card hand to prevent Riddles in the Dark from discarding Sting.

[Valtor]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Valtor$s1rywhcvzppqb4gb

This may already be reported, but Gandalf Leader of Dwarves is miscosted at 4 instead of the 2 it should be.

[Valtor]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Valtor$4dfqndznlivykdh6

When killed, Narzug Orkish Assassin allows owning player to wound two allies twice each. Should only be able to wound one ally twice. See site 3.

[Phallen Cassidy]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=zaksirak$wqiz92nz31dufpzu
Bolg didn't give damage bonus on site 2 and Narzog bugget game completely on site 4. Narzog did this to me twice today when I played on my iPhone. First time I was by PC, so i logged in and I could continue. On iPhone I just couldn't click anywere on the screen.

Are you certain you didn't have a button to pass the optional action from Narzug? No other players have reported a similar issue and I don't see anything that makes your replay unique.

Upon the next update:

- Narzug should no longer fire twice
- Gandalf, Leader of Dwarves will cost 2
- Azog, The Defiler will cost 4

Battle of Azanulbazar has the same error as Dawn Take You All, I think it's a misapplication of the rules rather than something on the card itself. Not sure if I know enough about the new Gemp structure to tackle it, but I'll check. It's also a rules-side issue for the prevention text in Riddles in the Dark as far as I can tell, these will probably be addressed by MarcinS.

Laketown's trigger is a workaround to allow the site's text to work, I think -- the trigger just resets the "first Orc played" counter for the next player.

[Valtor]

Thanks Phallen!

Will Gollum Small Slimy Creature get fixed as well?

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Valtor$1zp7wdnxw284dqmu

Another one: Bombur Chief Cook does not give Dam +1. See Zaksirak sites 2, 3, 5, 7 and 8, Valtor sites 2, 3, 4 and 6 (all when attached to Thorin except Zaksirak site 8 when attached to Dwalin)

[Durin's Heir]

In Valtor's game, Zaksirak's Dwalin was dmg+2 at site 8 due to Dwarven Axe (dmg+1 at a mountain). So Bombur is bugged regardless of bearer.

[Malachi]

At Site 5, Lore of Imladris healed both Gandalf and Bilbo. With Elrond on the table it should have been able to heal 2 Dwarven companions only.

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Malachi$0s54v7qmv2ulp9vl