I didn't see
librarian listed on your first decklist. On that one as well, is there a reason you're not using an extra copy or two of your key companions? Since
inspiration is key component of your set up here, extra companions will only help you out more. Are you going with a shadow side designed to eat your hand if necessary? In fact, you might throw in an extra hand eater or two since you know that every shadow turn you'll probably be sitting with 2 hobbits in hand so you'll need to make sure everything else freep is out of there.
The 2nd one actually looks stronger to me than the first.