0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
The source of a discard is always the card doing the discard.
I'm almost certain that he can't. "By an opponent" means "by an opponent's Shadow card". Because the source of the ability is the site, it does not fall in this category.
Quote from: Thranduil on May 12, 2010, 05:05:32 AMI'm almost certain that he can't. "By an opponent" means "by an opponent's Shadow card". Because the source of the ability is the site, it does not fall in this category.What would be your rationale for Siege Engine not working against BRC?
Are you saying there's a known ruling that makes Siege Engine not work against BRC?
Siege Engine can't prevent a Shadow player from discarding cards.Siege Engine can't prevent the effect of Blood Runs Chill. Even though Blood Runs Chill is a Free Peoples card, it makes a Shadow player discard.
Quote from: Thranduil on May 12, 2010, 04:36:32 PMAre you saying there's a known ruling that makes Siege Engine not work against BRC?This might look familiar:Quote from: 6/8/05 CRDSiege Engine can't prevent a Shadow player from discarding cards.Siege Engine can't prevent the effect of Blood Runs Chill. Even though Blood Runs Chill is a Free Peoples card, it makes a Shadow player discard.Same reasoning seems to imply Feared Axeman won't work against Pelennor Prairie, since it makes the Free Peoples player discard.