Simple question

[theoldwizard]

If I had multiple copies of Great Siege Towers in play when I play a besieger, do I place a token on each copy of Great Siege Towers, or do I choose which one to place the token on?

[Thranduil]

You put one on token on each one.

No you don't. You choose 1 copy to put 1 token on.

This is the difference between the two abilities:

"Shadow: Play a besieger to add a token here."

"Each time you play a besieger, you may add a token here."

In the second case, each copy of Great Siege Towers triggers and you get to put a token on each one.

In the first case, you can't combine special abilities and it's worded like a Shadow special ability (because it begins with "Shadow:") so you only get to put 1 token on 1 copy.

Thran

[Tbiesty]

Correct.

[theoldwizard]

Thanks for the replies, this has been confusing me for some time.

[LOTRFreak15]

Got it Thran. Thanks.

[macheteman]

same goes for siege engine. i remember when i used to think i'd get 4 tokens each time i played an uruk... ah, those were the days...

[LOTRFreak15]

Is the same for Attack on Helm's Deep?

[Ringbearer]

Exactly. Its a shadow action so one token per Uruk-Hai.