I am finding myself liking
On Your Doorstep more and more for any deck with Gandy--not sure how underrated it is
I think
A Path Appointed is quite useful for its purposes--I use one in a token-based fellowship after discovering it recently.
Derufin is a great splash--possibly underrated. He absoutely destroys tough machine uruk/berserkers.
I agree with jdizzy001 that Aragorn signets are great--definitely an underrated element (as well as Frodo sigs---however everybody knows
TMAYOD with Gandy sigs)
and sorry ket but your list definitely has power cards everybody is familiar with---Sam, SoH as underrated? really? lol
Fires Raged Unchecked : P