Post your Gemp-LotR bugs here

[jcb213]

Fixed, I hope it's the only one that can be transferred from minion to minion.

It should be.  All the others specify "from your support area" and Fifth Level doesn't, which is why it plays differently.

[Not a Zombie]

Southron Archer Legion should have a limit of +4 arrows, regardless of how many times he's used

[ramolnar]

Hi Marcin. Return to Its Master isn't quite correct:

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=ramolnar$w26a1c07sf5ay9c7

At site 8, in the first Return skirmish, the ring was on, the Nazgul won the skirmish, but the Response on the Ring could be used to add two burdens. I overwhelmed on the second Return skirmish, but should have won on the first.

And yes, I know this is a hard card.

[ramolnar]

More fun. Fear does not exert the Nazgul. See site 9:

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=ramolnar$9h50235t7059d6ee

This one is easier than RTIM, I bet.

Also, could you check to see if Galadriel can exert for no effect? See in that game.

[Not a Zombie]

Make light of burdens should only be able to discard conditions attached to dwarves or weather conditions, I saw it discard under the watching eye.

[Felagund]

To clarify ramolnar's comment about Galadriel:

Galadriel, Lady of Light should be able to exert for her ability even if you do not have a playable Elf in hand.  (This is similar to the way Cantea can exert when his opponent bears no weapon or even if he is not involved in a skirmish (which is allowed), you can play Secret Sentinels even if there are no shadow conditions (also allowed), etc.)

I haven't seen it, but the same bug probably affects Gandalf, The Grey Wizard if you have no playable companions in hand.

(This is relevant in case you have an extra Galadriel or Gandalf in hand and want to cycle the card to heal them.)

[NappyKorn]

better be careful using secret sentinels in there are no shadow conditions because then you will have to discard your own condition (or 2 if you can spot an orc). Not sure if that is an issue in this program but if it is it should be fixed to force the free peoples person to discard their conditions if no shadow condition is in play.


NK

[MarcinS]

Southron Archer Legion should have a limit of +4 arrows, regardless of how many times he's used

Fixed.

[MarcinS]

Hi Marcin. Return to Its Master isn't quite correct:

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=ramolnar$w26a1c07sf5ay9c7

At site 8, in the first Return skirmish, the ring was on, the Nazgul won the skirmish, but the Response on the Ring could be used to add two burdens. I overwhelmed on the second Return skirmish, but should have won on the first.

And yes, I know this is a hard card.

Should be fixed now.

[MarcinS]

More fun. Fear does not exert the Nazgul. See site 9:

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=ramolnar$9h50235t7059d6ee

This one is easier than RTIM, I bet.

Also, could you check to see if Galadriel can exert for no effect? See in that game.

Fear is fixed.

As for Galadriel, unless an effect it requires you to spot something before the "to" in text (if the "to" is in text), or it requires you to pay a cost and you cannot, then you can use the ability for no effect, including paying all the costs. The only exception is if an effect requires you to play a card (except from deck) you have to be able to play that card to use the effect.

So if that was the question, then the answer is - you can't exert Galadriel, Lady of Light if you have no playable Elf in hand.

[MarcinS]

Make light of burdens should only be able to discard conditions attached to dwarves or weather conditions, I saw it discard under the watching eye.

Fixed: - "Make Light of Burdens" should not be able to discard any condition anymore.

[MarcinS]

To clarify ramolnar's comment about Galadriel:

Galadriel, Lady of Light should be able to exert for her ability even if you do not have a playable Elf in hand.  (This is similar to the way Cantea can exert when his opponent bears no weapon or even if he is not involved in a skirmish (which is allowed), you can play Secret Sentinels even if there are no shadow conditions (also allowed), etc.)

I haven't seen it, but the same bug probably affects Gandalf, The Grey Wizard if you have no playable companions in hand.

(This is relevant in case you have an extra Galadriel or Gandalf in hand and want to cycle the card to heal them.)

You're wrong on that one. Let me point you to Comprehensive Rules:
"If an action plays a card from your hand (or discard pile) as part of its effect, then that card must be in your hand (or discard pile) before you can begin to perform that action."

[MarcinS]

better be careful using secret sentinels in there are no shadow conditions because then you will have to discard your own condition (or 2 if you can spot an orc). Not sure if that is an issue in this program but if it is it should be fixed to force the free peoples person to discard their conditions if no shadow condition is in play.

The program is working correctly. If you play Secret Sentinels you're given a choice of spotting an Orc (if there is one). Then you HAVE to choose 1 (or 2 if you chose to spot an Orc) conditions to discard, even if these are your conditions.

[Felagund]

Whoops.  Thanks for the clarification Marcin.

[NappyKorn]

Are you dsure you get to choose whether or not you can spot an orc if there is an orc in play for secret sentinels? Seems to me if there is infact an orc in play you have to spot it. I could be wrong and I guess this would be better brought up in the rules forums and not here on your thread.

Anyway i've been thinking of playing more on this program but im just not a person who likes to bounce from a program that ive finally got the hang of to another program im not that familiar with. I gave this program a try or two and do in fact like it, but I think I'll wait and give it another try once it is finished (all sets complete). It looks very good from the game (or two) I tried and look forward to getting more familiar with it in the future. Keep up the good work

NK