Post your Gemp-LotR bugs here

[sgtdraino]

I was wondering about this myself. It seems to me that you should be able to look through your own adventure deck whenever you want. Particularly because, if it's a deck you don't play very often, you might not remember what all sites you have.

[Merrick_H]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Merrick H$evh2fcd0onsiptd7

Eregion's Trails is not taking a snapshot of roaming minions - it is affecting them after they are assigned.

See the use at site 6 and 7 (no minions roaming).  Also please see the "Event" entry on page 11 of the CRD 4.0

Event

Some event cards affect only cards that are currently in play, even though their effects might seem to apply to cards played later in the same turn. These events take a "snapshot" of the current game state, and only those cards are affected.
Eregion's Trails ("Maneuver: Exert a ranger to make each roaming minion strength –3 until the regroup phase.") affects only minions that are roaming when that event is played.

Given I expect that with the current implementation, Deft in their movements might also have an issue, but it will require some play testing to figure that out.

Regards,

M_H

[bibfortuna25]

I ran into someone playing DITM a few weeks back, and it seemed to work correctly (as in, the next site was not yet in play, so it wasnt affected by the event).

[gordie124]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=gordie124$nlar82re7t983max

Right before opponent Lando moves to site 6, they use Sting and remove 2 twilight from the pool, although I have 3 orcs in my hand.

[Ringbearer]

There was only 2 to the pool.

[MarcinS]

With Legolas DH in play, my opponent was able to play Morgul Gates but not play a Nazgul. He shouldn't have been even able to play Morgul Gates if he couldn't play a Nazgul with it.

Should the playability check for the card "look ahead" into what will happen when you play the card? So, should it take into account the Legolas that is in play? At the moment it only takes into account the cost of the event when checking if player will have enough twilight to play the Nazgul.

[MarcinS]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Merrick H$evh2fcd0onsiptd7

Eregion's Trails is not taking a snapshot of roaming minions - it is affecting them after they are assigned.

See the use at site 6 and 7 (no minions roaming).  Also please see the "Event" entry on page 11 of the CRD 4.0

Event

Some event cards affect only cards that are currently in play, even though their effects might seem to apply to cards played later in the same turn. These events take a "snapshot" of the current game state, and only those cards are affected.
Eregion's Trails ("Maneuver: Exert a ranger to make each roaming minion strength –3 until the regroup phase.") affects only minions that are roaming when that event is played.

Given I expect that with the current implementation, Deft in their movements might also have an issue, but it will require some play testing to figure that out.

Regards,

M_H

Fixed (after restart):
- "Eregion's Trails" now makes a snapshot of affected cards upon being played and does not apply to any other cards.

I will also look at more cards to ensure they work correctly.

[bibfortuna25]

With Legolas DH in play, my opponent was able to play Morgul Gates but not play a Nazgul. He shouldn't have been even able to play Morgul Gates if he couldn't play a Nazgul with it.

Should the playability check for the card "look ahead" into what will happen when you play the card? So, should it take into account the Legolas that is in play? At the moment it only takes into account the cost of the event when checking if player will have enough twilight to play the Nazgul.

Yes it should take DH into account, because the cost of the event is no longer 0; it's 2.

[Rhyme]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Rhyme$o377n40gdnq8krme
site 4
my gimli, after i put on the one ring, it doesn't allow me to choose the armor to discard to prevent the wound, it automatically assign burden.  but before i put on the ring, it;s fine that i can choose to either use the armor or put on the ring.

[gordie124]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Rhyme$o377n40gdnq8krme
site 4
my gimli, after i put on the one ring, it doesn't allow me to choose the armor to discard to prevent the wound, it automatically assign burden.  but before i put on the ring, it;s fine that i can choose to either use the armor or put on the ring.

Once the ring is on, there are two simultaneous "Response" actions that can take place, one mandatory from the One Ring, RoR, and one optional from Gimli's Armor. Each is responding to the trigger -Gimli is about to take a wound-. The comprehensive rules are pretty clear about what is supposed to happen.

Some responses are performed when a described situation is "about to" happen. Typically, only one such response can be performed in a given situation, because its effect will "prevent" that situation or replace it with another effect "instead."

Example: Isildur is wearing The One Ring, Answer to All Riddles. ("While wearing The One Ring,... each time he is about to take a wound in a skirmish, add a burden instead.") The Free Peoples player has Sapling of the White Tree in play. ("Response: If a GONDOR Man is about to take a wound, discard this artifact to prevent that.") Isildur loses a skirmish and is about to take a wound. Because the required action of The One Ring causes a burden to be added "instead" of a wound, the optional action of Sapling of the White Tree cannot be used, as the situation it responds to no longer exists.

No bug. The rules were applied correctly.

[bibfortuna25]

That's not a bug. When the Ring is on, you can't use any "about to take a wound" actions, because the Ring's text automatically converts those wounds into burdens.

[Rhyme]

the Ring's text automatically converts those wounds into burdens.

but i the ring's text saids: "While the Ring-bearer is wearing The One Ring, each time he or she is about to take a wound, add a burden instead."
and the armor's text saids: "Bearer must be Gimli. Response: If you have initiative and Gimli is about to take a wound, discard 2 cards from hand to prevent that wound."

what is the different??  and why the ring must have priority?

my bad... i didn't see gordie124's responses...

[bibfortuna25]

http://gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=bibfortuna$bgx9uxrb6d6s2whu

Till Durin Wakes Again did not heal my opponent's Dwarves when he moved from site 5.

[MarcinS]

http://gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=bibfortuna$bgx9uxrb6d6s2whu

Till Durin Wakes Again did not heal my opponent's Dwarves when he moved from site 5.

Here is the game from your opponent's perspective:
http://gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Farusilha$jpz2biqancq0k7ot

All of the Till Durin Wakes Again light up when he moves. He must have clicked "Ok/Done" instead of using them. It's an optional trigger, therefore it doesn't happen automatically.

[dark293]

Putting burdens on a ring bearer wielding the ring ring of rings case being galadriel having resist 5 i bid 4 burdens and it auto corrupted me even though with base stats and ring i should of had 5 http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?gameId=16392