Bill the Ponny
- INCORRECT?
I bealive (and correct me if I am wrong) - Bill the Ponny works incorrectly. Once you are comming to the underground site, it first deduct shadow number and then discard. See here:
https://play.lotrtcgpc.net/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Izaren$nsc5cu4gyvut5327
This is not according to the rule book. I have found only 2 rules of the Fell Rulebook which may be applied to this case:
A) in the end of the section 1 (Fellowship) of the rulebook "How to move" is stated you first move your marker (which i gues means the fellowship is already there and Bill shall be discarted) and only after this you add twilight for site. This is even supported by the further updates of rulebooks (for example Siege of Gondor rulebook is even more detailed regarding order of actions and it also specifies that you first move to the site (so
BtP shall be discarted) and only after you add the twilight for shadow number and at last twilight for companios)
B) in the rulebook is section "timing conflict" which states that if two events occuer at the same time the FP player shall decide in what order they occure (so there should be at least option to decide - not automatic deduction). Still, I dont think it occurs at the same time since I consider option A as more realistic.
So I am just curious, on what rule is the current seting of
BtP based? Did I miss any relevant section of the rulebook? Otherwise I wwould recommend adjustments of the mechanics of this card.
Thanks in advance for corretion of the card or of my opinion =)