Post your Gemp-LotR bugs here

[Victauic]

https://play.lotrtcgpc.net/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=victaulic$t93anmusev67i5oz

Site 8: I played dawn take you all and triggered Gandalf's effect to wound a minion when a gandalf event is played, i clicked the spider because i forgot you cant target smaug with gandalfs effect so it would automatically hit the spider, but it allowed me to target the spider with the wound a minion twice effect from Dawn Take You All even though it only had one vitality left, i would assume smaug would be the only legal target in this instance since he had 2 vitality left and spider only had one.

[Dori]

Opponent replaced Doorway to Doom in PC. This happened in a previous game too.

https://play.lotrtcgpc.net/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Dori$x8jmrg45p33s5iy5

[Orophoin]

As the card is worded, this isn't a bug.

A site's text is only active when the fellowship is at that site (otherwise, for example, The Prancing Pony could be used every turn). Since your opponent wasn't at that site, it could freely be replaced.

Mount Doom is different because it had the text "for the rest of the game", so once the text is activated (by a fellowship moving to it), it is in place forever. Even that site can be replaced before a fellowship moves there, however.

Perhaps this is one for the PC to consider rewording, as it's just as abusive as always as things stand.

[TelTura]

I'm actually going to push back on that long-standing community ruling (not a Decipher ruling).  Having reviewed it, I'm not sure that it stands the sniff test. 

I have posted in the Mount Doom thread here: https://lotrtcgwiki.com/forums/index.php?topic=2592.msg99446#msg99446

[daisukeman]

Hey team!
Minor bug:
Remember those pesky NULL messages whenever cards give you choices?

Well, this time it is back in the form of "Leaping blaze":
https://ibb.co/BZ4zkdx
Keep up the great work!

[daisukeman]

Another one I just remember, though I don't have a replay link...

Galadriel's Glade http://wiki.lotrtcgpc.net/wiki/LOTR01351 site, doesn't summarize in text (at the chat) what were the opponent's cards which were shown...
Compare it to Sting or other cards, they do keep up the handy annotation.

[TelTura]

Another one I just remember, though I don't have a replay link...

Galadriel's Glade http://wiki.lotrtcgpc.net/wiki/LOTR01351 site, doesn't summarize in text (at the chat) what were the opponent's cards which were shown...
Compare it to Sting or other cards, they do keep up the handy annotation.

So this one is down to a difference of wording.  "Reveal" effects put the info into the chat, while "look at" does not.  https://wiki.lotrtcgpc.net/wiki/Comprehensive_Rules_4.1#effect :

"When an effect says a player should look at a card, that card is shown only to that player.

When an effect says to reveal a card, that card is shown to all players. "


At the moment there's no real difference between the two in a 2-player game, but Gemp was built with multiplayer in mind at least, and keeps such information private (as it would need to be if there was a third player watching).  There might be room to argue that 2-player matches should treat "look at" and "reveal" the same for this.

[TelTura]

Hey team!
Minor bug:
Remember those pesky NULL messages whenever cards give you choices?

Well, this time it is back in the form of "Leaping blaze":
https://ibb.co/BZ4zkdx
Keep up the great work!

This one could stand to have a replay if you have one, but I'll take a look regardless.

[daisukeman]

I see, thanks for the explanation.
For the one about NULL msg, here ya go:
https://play.lotrtcgpc.net/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=daisukeman$jxde21aje7auuepz

[Jango]

I am reporting the disappearance of Enquea LOM from Gemp. I don't have it in my promotional cards. Instead I got the Goblin Runner. I do not know why.

Please restore this promotional Card

[TelTura]

Oh dang it, I must have screwed up the IDs when I added the WC cards.  I will get that fixed ASAP.

[TelTura]

Okay, this has now been fixed.  All Full Art Enquea owners should now find those copies right where you left them (including in decks), and all WC Goblin Runner recipients should find 4x of those in My Cards completely separately.  If anyone added a WC Goblin Runner to their deck in the last 24 hours or so, please double-check those decks (it is almost certainly a Full Art Enquea at the moment).  Nobody else should need to adjust any decks.

[daisukeman]

Hi All,
For your consideration, 2 bugs in the hobbit draft format:

1. Strangest game ever with Bard deciding to lurk on Bilbo:
https://play.lotrtcgpc.net/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=daisukeman$2j3d6vkfpir27w24
Please ask my opponent though about whatever he was able to do to get Bard to act like the ring, being able to use his regroup abilities...

2. Smaug's awakening, not possible to take the event back in hand.
Site 4 in this one after clicking "Yes" nothing happened:
https://play.lotrtcgpc.net/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=daisukeman$qlqsejeil89qycfg

[Couatl]

https://play.lotrtcgpc.net/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Couatl$dn9olxnqtyw2j5g9

on site 6 i have lost initiative once during fellowship phase and then drawn up to 4 cards again and for some reason i cannot use gimli's armor
and then in the regroup phase i loose initiative again and it loyalty unshaken triggers and i stack 2 cards on it and instead of drawing up to 8 during reconcile i draw up to 6 as the game thinks the 2 cards i stacked are stacked after drawing up to 8
further on site 2 i cannot exert twice a minion with 2 vitality and instead exert twice a minion with 4 vitality
the game does it automatically instead of giving me the option to choose

[Orophoin]

https://play.lotrtcgpc.net/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=Couatl$dn9olxnqtyw2j5g9

on site 6 i have lost initiative once during fellowship phase and then drawn up to 4 cards again and for some reason i cannot use gimli's armor
and then in the regroup phase i loose initiative again and it loyalty unshaken triggers and i stack 2 cards on it and instead of drawing up to 8 during reconcile i draw up to 6 as the game thinks the 2 cards i stacked are stacked after drawing up to 8
further on site 2 i cannot exert twice a minion with 2 vitality and instead exert twice a minion with 4 vitality
the game does it automatically instead of giving me the option to choose

The rules say that if you have a choice, you must choose the action you can most fully perform. In the car if your site 2, you are trying to exert a minion twice. You can exert the troll twice, but you can't do it to the assassin (with it only being able to reset once), so the game automatically selects the troll for you.

At site 6, you let Gimlin be overwhelmed by the troll. So he didn't take any wounds for the armour to prevent; he just died.

However, only drawing to six cards at the reconcile does look to me like a bug. I imagine that is the first time it's been seen before as you're combining an X-list card and a rarely seen one in Loyalty Unshaken. How strange