I know there is a proposal to merge the two Rohan decks, but I like the feel of each of them as they stand. I don't think it is too much to have 2 rohan decks as there is a TON of rohan stuff in towers and the other cultures still have significant presence. Putting them in series 1 and 3 mean that you will have to get through series 2 before you can merge them which is a plus.
I'd love to hear thoughts from folks!
I have the impression that no one listens/reads what I say...
as there are no counterarguments.Elves appear at 3rd Serie (in only half a deck). Same with Hobbits. Gondor have a whole Serie for themselves. There's no presence of Ents nor Gandalf (in full height)...
I don't see a significant presence of anything but Gondor.
Those 2 Rohan decks work in
almost the same way (except for some Gandalf presence), so it seems to me a waste of deck space. Each has little to contribute to the other, and are by themselves somewhat inefficient:
1. The 1st Serie one, "Rohan Allies", has only 3 allies and not a single
Well Stored (relies on Eomer only for healing), while my merged draft has 5 allies and 2 of that condition.
2. The Valiant deck, "Gandalf & Rohan", lacks the only non-rare Valiant-themed card (out of a huge pool of only 3) that makes reasonable to build a Valiant deck (
Let Us Be Swift), has 2 'valiant-themed' allies (the other 2 cards of the pool) but no way of using one of them (
Sigewulf needs to spot 5 Valiant men to be 'useful', the deck
provides only 4)...
My draft merges those 2 themes with more power and versatility (condition control, more healing, more possession replay, reusable pumping-allies, even archery but that can be trimmed if found OP) and very good coupling potential (
Weland,
Leod, mounts,
An Honorable Charge), saving a valuable deck slot for other purposes (Ents, a Gandalf-centered deck,
Hard Choice,
Wingfoot-UB Hobbits...). Can merge well with a Gandalf
TMAYOD for that purpose. Gandalf should be a resource accessible to all and not only to Rohirrim or (in a little degree) to Dwaves, he should have his own deck at Serie 2.
Limiting Gandalf to: 1) Just some little presence inside only two decks, instead of a full deck for himself, 2) Having to choose Rohan in order to get
TMAYOD, or Dwarves to get only condition control and
very little more, and 3) A very late apparition as he's elegible (in greater but not full height) at the 3rd and last Serie...
is in my opinion A CRIME.
My conclusion: "Valiant + Allies Rohan" deck at the 1st Serie, "Gandalf
TMAYOD" at the 2nd Serie.
Here's again that merged Rohan deck draft:
2x
Household Guard2x
Theoden, King of the Golden Hall1x
Eomer, Forthwith Banished1x
Eowyn, Daughter of Eomund1x
Ecglaf, Courageous Farmer1x
Guma, Plains Farmer1x
Hlafwine, Village Farmhand1x
Leod, Westfold Herdsman1x
Weland, Smith of the Riddermark1x
Brego1x
Herugrim2x
Horse of Rohan2x
Rider's Spear2x
Rohirrim Bow2x
Hobbit Sword2x
An Honorable Charge1x
Let Us Be Swift2x
Severed His Bonds1x
Armory1x
Arrow-slits2x
Well StoredI owe you the Gandalf
TMAYOD decklist (I'm working on it). Might be merged with Ents in order to: 1) give companion support, and 2) eliminate Ents from the waiting list...
Proposed Pairings by Series
Serie 1:
Gandalf & Dwarves/Sauron Trackers (Grind)
Rohan Allies/Moria & Isengard Archery
Three Hunters/Uruk Trackers
Serie 2:
Knights/Dunland Discard
Unbound Rangers/Twilight Nazgul
Ringbound Companions/Easterlings & Gollum
Serie 3:
Shoulder to Shoulder/Southrons
Hobbits & Smeagol/Rohirrim Traitors
Gandalf & Rohan/Berserkers
I like the idea of having both heavy wounding shadows (Sauron Grind and Archery) in the 1st Serie, and both corruption shadows at the 2nd. However, Southrons deck at the 3rd is a Grind + Beatdown mixture, that might be troublesome if coupled with Archery or Sauron Grind...
Serie 2 is only Gondor... that's awful. You can't couple them that way. Change one of those fellowships (not the Knight one) to the 3rd Serie. Replacing the
needless Rohan & Gandalf deck. Gandalf
TMAYOD (or Gandalf+Ents) can be in the 2nd Serie (and coupling Rohan from 1st with Gandalf from 2nd gets that Rohan & Gandalf deck, and much more).
Berserkers should be in Serie 2, as almost everything they need is from set 5. Paired with Gandalf.
"Ringbound Companions" at Serie 2
is a deceiving name... it only has RB Rangers and some little Frodo/Sam protection; it lacks Smeagol. I would suggest it to be merged with the Smeagol deck, but both themes require too many slots for tricks and set up... Therefore, merge those RB Rangers with the UB ones and name the result 'Rangers deck'... or at least change that fake name to 'Ringbound Rangers'.
Hope this helps and doesn't offend anyone...
EDIT: I just made a 'Gandalf
TMAYOD + Ents' deck that is apparently ok, but won't post it until the debate about Rohan decks and Gondor domain at Serie 2 advances a little... to not dilute attention.