Humm, what an interesting replay. For starters, you did indeed draw 2 cards, it just wasn't until after that insanely long loop of the tentacles all having a bunch of required triggers--I don't really understand why they did, but they did, and then you drew
Foul Things and
Scouring of the Shire (perhaps they didn't visibly show and the tentacle lag time would have required a refresh?).
In the case of Scouring, well. Scouring specifically states "If a
![Shire [Shire]](https://lotrtcgdb.com/forums/Smileys/classic/shire.png)
condition...is about to be discarded from play by a Shadow card". Consorting was discarded by
Buckland Homestead, which is a Site, and is neither Shadow nor Free Peoples.
Thanks for the elusive tentacle replay however, I've been hunting this bug for a while.